Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Travel the Seven Seas's avatar

"Imagine what would have happened if the Battle of Red Cliff (208AD) had ended with Cao Cao winning." You posted an interesting question at the beginning of this post.

Among the three rivals, Cao Cao was the most brilliant man, at least in literary talent, if not statemenship. However, as we all know, history is not simply an IQ test for ambitious players.

If I could choose, I would certainly prefer the prolonged three-kingdom state to a quick return to boring dynastic rule. Let's face it: what periods in China's long history produced the deepest talent pool of philosophers, thinkers, and scholars? Most people would agree on the Three-Kingdom, the Spring and Autumn, and the Warring States periods. Territorial wars were generally terrible, but competition between warlords sometimes had the unintended consequences of promoting talent development.

BTW, if Cao Cao had won a decisive war at the Red Cliff, we probably would have lost one of the four pillars of Classic Chinese literature.

Expand full comment

No posts